Ghost of Tsushima 2 Might be Correct in Replacing Jin That Many Fans Won’t Accept (But it’s True)

Ghost of Tsushima was a massive hit when it launched in 2020, with players falling in love with the stunning open world, engaging combat, and emotional story of Jin Sakai’s journey from samurai to the legendary Ghost.

However, not everyone was entirely satisfied with the game’s protagonist, as one player’s recent critique has sparked a discussion about Jin’s personality and whether a new lead character in the sequel might be a good idea.

While the idea of replacing Jin in Ghost of Tsushima 2 might seem sacrilegious to some fans, there are valid arguments for why a fresh perspective could benefit the series and open up new storytelling possibilities.

Ghost of Tsushima: Jin Sakai’s Personality or the Lack Thereof

In a post on the r/patientgamers subreddit, user u/eu4player90 shared their thoughts on Ghost of Tsushima after completing the game, and while they praised many aspects of the experience, they had some harsh words for Jin Sakai himself:

Ghost of Tsushima is beautiful, but insanely repetitive and dull
byu/eu4player90 inpatientgamers

The user’s main criticism is that Jin lacks a distinct personality, with his unwavering focus on honor and the game’s tropes about the samurai code making him feel one-dimensional. They argue that even when the story tries to show a different side of Jin, it always comes back to the same themes, leaving the protagonist feeling flat and uninteresting.

While this assessment is subjective, it raises a valid point about the potential limitations of tying the Ghost of Tsushima series so closely to one character. If Jin’s personality and arc are already feeling repetitive to some players after one game, it could be a challenge to keep his story engaging across multiple sequels.

The Ghost as a Symbol, Not Just a Person

While Jin Sakai is undoubtedly the face of Ghost of Tsushima, it’s important to remember that the “Ghost” is more than just one man. Throughout the game, we see how the legend of the Ghost grows, striking fear into the hearts of the Mongol invaders and inspiring hope among the people of Tsushima.

In many ways, the Ghost is a symbol, an idea that transcends any one individual. Much like how the mantle of Captain America or Black Panther can be passed down to worthy successors in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the role of the Ghost could potentially be taken up by a new character in a sequel.

Introducing a new protagonist in Ghost of Tsushima 2 could be an opportunity to explore this idea further. Perhaps Jin takes on a mentor role, passing the mantle of the Ghost to a worthy successor who brings their own unique perspective and personality to the story. Or maybe the sequel takes place years later, with a new character taking up the Ghost’s mask to fight against a different threat to Tsushima.

By shifting the focus away from Jin as an individual, Ghost of Tsushima 2 could open up new narrative possibilities while still staying true to the themes and spirit of the first game. It would also give players a chance to form a fresh connection with a new character, rather than feeling like they’re retreading familiar ground with Jin.

Of course, the decision ultimately lies with Sucker Punch and their creative vision for the series. But if the goal is to deliver another unforgettable experience, exploring new characters and perspectives could be a refreshing change of pace.

At the end of the day, what matters most is that Ghost of Tsushima 2 captures the same sense of adventure, beauty, and emotion that made the first game so special. Whether that’s with Jin Sakai at the helm or a new hero rising to the challenge, fans will undoubtedly be eager to return to the setting of Tsushima.

What do you think about the idea of replacing Jin Sakai in Ghost of Tsushima 2? Do you agree that his personality falls flat, or do you think he’s an integral part of what makes the series work? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!