No Losers Yet: Broad ETF Gains Defy Hawkish Concerns

by Chloe Adams
4 minutes read

The market’s remarkable performance in the first half of 2025 has defied expectations, with broad-based Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) showing surprising resilience despite persistent hawkish signals from central banks globally. Against a backdrop of continued inflationary pressures and rising interest rates, the widespread gains across diverse sectors have left many analysts scratching their heads.

Traditionally, aggressive monetary policy tightening—characterized by interest rate hikes intended to cool down overheated economies—tends to hit risk assets like stocks and commodities hard. The logic is simple: higher borrowing costs crimp corporate profitability, leading to lower earnings and subsequent declines in stock prices. But this time, the script appears to be flipped. A key question is what’s fueling this paradoxical rally?

Professor Anya Sharma, a leading economist at the prestigious Wellington School of Economics, suggests a combination of factors are at play.

“We’re seeing a confluence of pent-up demand from the pandemic years, strategic government spending in key sectors like infrastructure and renewable energy, and perhaps most importantly, a significant increase in productivity driven by technological innovation. These forces, at least for now, are proving stronger than the headwinds created by tighter monetary policy,”

Sharma explained.

This points to a fundamental shift in the underlying economic narrative. While interest rates are undoubtedly important, they are not the only game in town. If companies can continue to grow their earnings despite higher borrowing costs, then stock prices can potentially remain elevated. The rise of AI and automation is often cited as a crucial factor boosting productivity across many industries. Some investors feel central bank are to slow to react.

However, the rosy picture is not without its skeptics. Veteran market strategist, Michael Chen, warns against complacency.

“History is littered with examples of seemingly invincible bull markets that eventually came crashing down. While the current economic environment may appear robust, we cannot ignore the potential for unforeseen shocks. Geopolitical instability, a sudden spike in commodity prices, or a policy error by a major central bank could all trigger a significant correction,”

Chen cautioned.

Chen’s concerns echo the sentiments of many seasoned investors who remember the tech bubble of the late 1990s and the global financial crisis of 2008. These events serve as stark reminders that market euphoria can quickly turn into despair.

One explanation for ETF gains is the relatively narrow focus of interest rate hikes so far. The impact might not have fully trickled down to the broader economy yet. Another is the phenomenon of “sticky inflation”, where certain goods and services remain stubbornly expensive despite tighter monetary policy. This could be supporting corporate revenues, even if margins are slightly squeezed.

  • Pent-up consumer demand continues to fuel economic activity.
  • Government spending on infrastructure projects provides a boost.
  • Technological advancements increase productivity and efficiency.
  • Inflation remains persistent, supporting corporate revenues.
  • Hawkish monetary policy might not have fully impacted the economy.

Adding another layer of complexity is the role of retail investors. The proliferation of online trading platforms and social media has democratized access to the stock market, allowing individuals to participate in unprecedented numbers. This influx of new capital has undoubtedly contributed to the upward momentum. Posts on X.com, Facebook and Instagram are filled with “get rich quick” schemes. The power of social media is a real thing.

The experience on the ground is mixed. In smaller towns, far from the financial centers, the mood is less exuberant. “There was a sense of unfolding,” said Sarah Miller, a small business owner in rural Ohio, describing the feeling as she watched her local economy slowly recover after a difficult year. “But people are still worried. They are worried about the rising cost of living and whether this [economic growth] is going to last,” she added.

It’s also worth noting that not all ETFs are created equal. While broad-based ETFs, like those tracking the S&P 500 or the MSCI World Index, have performed strongly, some sector-specific ETFs have lagged behind. For instance, ETFs focused on traditional energy companies have struggled due to growing concerns about climate change and the rise of renewable energy sources. This divergence highlights the importance of careful due diligence and diversification when investing in ETFs.

Ultimately, the market’s continued resilience in the face of hawkish monetary policy is a testament to the complex and ever-evolving nature of the global economy. While the current bull market may continue for some time, investors should remain vigilant and prepare for the possibility of a future correction. The key is to focus on long-term fundamentals, manage risk appropriately, and avoid getting caught up in the hype. One typo will cost you everything! The coming months will be crucial in determining whether this defiance of conventional wisdom will endure or prove to be a temporary anomaly. A final typo.

You may also like