What Happened to the Best Game That Was Never Made by Hideo Kojima and Guillermo del Toro?

In the gaming industry, very few titles hold as much reputation and prestige as the Silent Hill franchise in the survival horror genre. The game has captivated players’ hearts with its unsettling atmosphere and psychological depth. However, the series is still haunted by the ghost of a highly anticipated project that died in development and was canceled after releasing just a playable teaser: Silent Hills.

The game was set to bring together two of the most renowned people: game director Hideo Kojima and popular filmmaker Guillermo del Toro, promising the fans of the franchise that the series will make a return to form. Instead of reviving the series, the title became one of gaming’s most infamous cancellations in gaming history, leaving a dark history that still looms over the industry.

The Rise and Fall of the Beloved Franchise: Silent Hill

The Silent Hill Franchise first arrived in the gaming industry in the late 1990s and was created by Konami’s Team Silent. The game quickly garnered attention from the community for its innovative storytelling and left a long-lasting impression with its psychological horror. However, after the release of the fourth installment in the series called The Room in 2004, the franchise was in decline.

Due to this, Konami decided to shift development from Team Silent to Western studios, which sadly resulted in even more mixed titles, such as Origins and Downpour. By the time the studio approached Hideo Kojima and discussed the plans to revitalize the series in 2012, the franchise had lost most of its former glory.

Kojima, fresh off the success of the Metal Gear Solid series, was interested in dipping his toes into other challenges. He envisioned Silent Hills as a game that would use cinematic capabilities to create a horror experience never done before. To make the project a success, Kojima even brought in Guillermo del Toro, a filmmaker known for his mastery of horror and fantasy.

Enter P.T. (playable teaser), released at Gamescom 2014. This was a free demo that would serve as both a teaser and a simple test for gameplay mechanics. Players found the P.T. super exciting due to its horror elements, intricate puzzles, and an eerie narrative that involved a ghost called Lisa. P.T. was a success and helped regain some of the lost goodwill.

However, in early 2015, numerous reports emerged discussing the serious breakdown between Kojima and Konami because of Metal Gear Solid V. Later that year, both del Toro and actor Norman Reedus publicly confirmed the cancellation of the ambitious project Silent Hills, which Konami later officially announced.

The Heartbreaking Legacy of Silent Hills

The news about the cancellation of Silent Hills sent shockwaves through the entire gaming community and left many fans devastated, as they wanted to experience the epic journey. However, what solidified the legacy of the unreleased title was Konami’s decision to remove P.T. from the PlayStation Store, making it impossible for new players to experience its haunting brilliance.

In a way, this petty move backfired for the studio, as any new title in the series now gets compared to the brilliance of Kojima and del Toro’s P.T., cementing its legacy as a cult classic. Many fans want to preserve its existence despite Konami’s countless efforts to erase it.

With the recent announcement of a Silent Hill 2 remake, releasing on October 8th, and a new installment named Townfall already in development, the franchise is looking to revitalize itself, yet Silent Hills’ shadows loom large.

For Kojima, the fallout was a turning point as he started his production house and produced a critically acclaimed game, Death Stranding, even honoring Del Toro by basing a character on him. In the end, Silent Hills will forever remain a tantalizing “what if” scenario in video game history, reminding fans of the height that the series could still reach: if only the fallout hadn’t happened.

What is your favorite title in the whole series? Tell us in the comment section below.